Give Me a J-51 Expanding Tax Abatement Program Will Help With Co-op & Condo Maintenance

New York State Senator Tony Avella and Assemblyman Edward Braunstein, (center), speak at a press conference about the J-51 tax abatement bill on June 27, 2016 (Office of State Senator Tony Avella)

Editor’s Note:  The web article  published on 7/14/16 “Give Me a J-51” by John Zurz on legislation sponsored by State Sen. Tony Avella and Assemblyman Edward Braunstein  on the J-51 tax abatement program, has been corrected to clarify that the bills have not yet been signed into law by Gov. Andrew Cuomo.  The bills received unanimous legislative support and await Cuomo’s signature or veto. Additionally, New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio recently approved separate legislation to extend the program to June 30, 2019.

Described as a thoroughly unsexy issue, the J-51 tax abatement for co-ops and condos is proposed to be expanded to $32,000, thanks to bills sponsored by New York State State Assemblyman Edward Braunstein (D-26) and Senator Tony Avella (D-11). 

The legislation has passed the State Senate and Assembly, and now awaits Gov. Andrew Cuomo's signature or veto, although there is every indication he will sign it into law.

Extended in New York City

On the local level, Mayor Bill de Blasio recently signed Intro 1118, a local law which amended New York City's real property law, and extended the J-51 tax abatement program for city properties through June 30, 2019.

The J-51 tax abatement program was meant to give a tax abatement to residential apartment buildings, and co-ops and condos with assessments under $30,000, that are undergoing renovations.  Originally begun in 1955 as a way to encourage building owners to install hot water plumbing in their properties, since then, the program has expanded to include just about every major capital improvement you could name, including things like window replacements, elevator replacements and upgrades, electrical rewiring, major roof repair, plumbing overhauls, major façade work, and sewer line repairs. In addition to benefiting landlords, the J-51 abatement is also available to developers converting commercial or industrial buildings to residential, and to rental buildings converting to co-op or condo.

The program was expanded again in 1992 to include co-ops and condos with an assessment of $40,000 or less. In 2013, New York City revised the program to only cover co-ops and condos with assessments under $30,000 that are undergoing renovations. Any building that is part of this program would be able to recover about 75 percent of the costs of the improvements they made on the building and due to the fact it can potentially take years to be approved, these benefits are retroactive. By using the J-51 program, co-ops and condos are able to keep maintenance fees down and save residents money while still making repairs and improvements on the buildings they live in.

Money for Renovations

In a statement, the president of the Glen Oaks Village Co-op, Bob Friedrich, who is also the founder and co-president of The President's Co-op Council, a coalition of board presidents in Queens, said: “As president of the largest garden apartment co-op in New York, I cannot understate the importance of the J-51 tax exemption program.  We just completed installing over 18,000 new energy efficient windows in Glen Oaks Village.  We could not have done this without the benefit of the J-51 abatements that provided nearly 38 percent of the cost of this massive program in dollar for dollar tax reductions.  

“Without the J-51 program, monthly maintenance would have had to increase 16 percent to fully pay for these new windows, which would have been devastating to many of our seniors and working class families.  This issue is not sexy and does not garner much conversation around the dinner table, but is truly one of the most important programs that help keep our affordable co-ops affordable.”

The original proposal called for co-ops and condos with assessments of $50,000 or less to gain access to the J-51 program, but it eventually was settled on $32,000 with a cost of living increase every year that would max out at assessments of $35,000 or less.

“It was one of a number of issues that the co-op presidents brought to our attention and was something we wanted to do right away,” said Avella.

Reaching the Summit

Last December, Avella and New York State Senator Jeffrey D. Klein, D-34, both of whom represent Queens and the Bronx, conducted a two-day summit in which the property tax classification issue and the J-51 abatement were discussed with local co-op and condominium associations and board presidents.

“Out of those meetings, a number of issues came up, but it’s not only learning about what issues face co-ops and condos but how to mobilize what can be a real political force that before now hasn’t made its impact on the city,” said Avella. “So our goal was two-fold: to find out what we need to do to help, and then to get them organized so they can get some real attention and things done.”

John Zurz is a staff writer for The Cooperator and other publications.

Related Articles

New York State to Give Homeowners a Break After New Federal Tax Law

Gov. Cuomo Issues Order to Allow Property Owners to Prepay Their Taxes

How NY Homeowners Can Benefit From the STAR Program

Be Also Mindful of Some Recent Changes

Report: Condos See Higher Taxes as Abatements Expire

Property Owners Have Seen Monthly Tax Bills Double and Even Triple

Momentum Behind Pied-à-Terre Tax Stalls

NYC Real Estate Industry Lobbies Against Tax on Luxury Second Homes

Support for Pied-à-Terre Tax Grows

Albany Lawmakers Push for Taxing Second Homes

Taking Flight to Florida?

Hit Hard by Trump Tax Plan, NY Homeowners Look to the Sunshine State

 

2 Comments

  • Thanks for the article Mr. Zurz. As our HDFC co-op recently underwent a $3 million structural rehab, but collected only $9,000 a year in J-51 tax reductions from this, I'd like to know if we should have gotten more of a tax break. I was;t clear from your article what you mean by $30,000 or $32,000 in "assessments." Our co-op shareholders pay maintenance, to offset the cost of running the building, and an additional "assessment" of a few hundred dollars a month to cover the cost of the loan we took to pay for the work. What assessments are you referring to? What does the $32,000 limit refer to? I'm also intrigued when you quote a condo association president as saying that they were able to write off 38% of the window cost with a J-51 credit. Perhaps you could follow this up and explain how this works for co-ops? Thanks
  • By assessments, Peter meant on the real estate tax formula, not the additional assessment added to the base maintenance. A J-51 property tax exemption effectively freezes a building’s assessed value for tax purposes, so the owner does not have to pay property tax on the increase in value resulting from the rehabilitation work. In the case of a building worth $1 million before the work is done, and $2 million after the rehabilitation work, with a J-51 exemption the building owner pays taxes only on the initial $1 million assessed value, less any abatement as described above. The law specifies certain classes of work that are eligible for J-51 benefits, without making a distinction between exemptions and abatements. However, abatements are much more common than exemptions, because in order for a building to receive an exemption, the rehabilitation work must have increased the assessed value of the property. Only major upgrades will have an appreciable effect on property values. Therefore most rehabilitation work qualifies for J-51 abatements, but not exemptions. In most cases, the buildings that do receive exemptions are also eligible to receive abatements. http://www1.nyc.gov/site/hpd/developers/tax-incentives-j51.page