Passing on Co-ops When Executors' Rights Clash With the Board

Maintaining authority over sales by estates has become a difficult challenge for co-op boards of

directors. It is essential for co-ops to be reasonably assured that future maintenance payments will be made and that they will be able to control occupancy. Yet the case law has not been particularly helpful.

A recent court decision in Cavanagh v. 133-22nd Street Jackson Heights, Inc., held that an executor of an estate could sell a co-op apartment without board approval if there is no specific language in the proprietary lease requiring the executor to seek approval. In this case, the court decided in favor of permitting a sale without board approval for a variety of reasons. These included the principle that the law does not favor restrictions on the assignment of a lease, as well as the policy in favor of an executor's duty to settle an estate with due diligence. Therefore, the executor of an estate would not be bound by the general restrictions on assignment in a proprietary lease that does not make a specific reference to executors. Yet, this issue only represents the tip of the iceberg in dealing with a co-op's concerns.

Protecting the Co-op's Rights

One might think that all that needs to be done to protect the co-op in light of the Cavanaugh decision would be to add a reference to executors in the section of the proprietary lease dealing with board approval. It appears, however, that this kind of provision might not be upheld by the courts. The policy that discourages restrictions on the assignment of leases may frustrate the board's prerogative to approve new purchasers, even if the proprietary lease refers specifically to estates or other transfers in addition to the usual voluntary assignments.

Read More...

Related Articles

Alternative Dispute Resolution

What to Do When They Sue – Part II

Paul Manafort's 2 NYC Apartments Up For Sale

Other Properties May Follow

Inheriting a Co-op or Condo: What’s Involved?

There Are Issues When It Comes to Transferring Property

 

3 Comments

  • I have a similar situation where i am currently living in a co-op in which my deceased grandparents are the shareholders, but my father continued to reside there after they passed. I came back to take care of my father who is now a recent deceadent. I have been appointed administrator of my grandparents estate but the estate is the co-op. Do I have any rights? mgray14@nyc.rr.com
  • Hi, is there any existing law that says that co-op board must give a writen reason for a denil of a buyer. thanks
  • Upon a death iof the leasee, can a propriertory lease be copied from an existing one (with names changed for ownership) and registered with the required notarization? I wondered if a lawyer has to draw up the document, if we already have the correct wording and can have the document notarized.