Q&A: Does a Board Resolution at a Mitchell-Lama Building Become Part of the House Rules?

Q. When the board of a New York City Mitchell-Lama co-op requires the shareholders to purchase homeowners’ insurance, does the resolution, if passed, becomes part of the building’s house rules?  If there are no city-approved house rules, does the homeowners’ insurance obligation get attached to the occupancy agreement? 

                                   —Inquisitive Tenant

A. “The question seems to be one of corporate procedure,” says Andrew P. Brucker, a partner at the New York-based law firm of Montgomery McCracken Walker & Rhoads LLP. “When the board of a co-op (whether a Mitchell-Lama or not) passes a resolution, it is very important for it to be precise. Therefore, if the board wanted to pass a new house rule (technically called rules and regulations), the resolution should have specifically designated it as an amendment to the house rules. Then after it passed, it should have been sent out to all of the shareholders, and printed on the document which contains the house rules.

“If the resolution is not made a part of rules and regulations, I am not sure how it would be enforced. The rules and regulations are enforced under the terms of the occupancy agreement as if they were a default in the occupancy agreement. The occupancy agreement itself references the rules and regulations for this very reason.

“It would be extremely hard to believe that there are no rules and regulations. The original Mitchell-Lama occupancy agreement (created decades ago) has a set of rules and regulations printed right under the signatures. Therefore, unless for some reason all rules and regulations were deleted by an act of the board and shareholders (which was somehow approved by HPD [Housing Preservation and Development]), there are rules and regulations for every Mitchell-Lama.”

Related Articles

Q&A: Question About the Value of Shares After a Cooperator Dies

Q&A: Question About the Value of Shares After a Cooperator Dies

Q&A: My HDFC Co-op Won’t Transfer My Late Father’s Shares to Me

Q&A: My HDFC Co-op Won’t Transfer My Late Father’s Shares to Me

Mitchell-Lama Co-ops

The Pressure to Privatize

 

2 Comments

  • Question: Can any board member in a Mitchell-Lama Co-op request an emergency board meeting? I was told by another board member that the president and vice president are the only members that are allowed to request an emergency board meeting.
  • I live in a Mitchell-lama since 1992 and never received a copy of the complete house rules. I have been assaulted by a neighbors husband he is not a tenant on record yet lives here and very dangerous person. Does HPD investigate background check for all family members before granting approval! And is he required to show his income to HPD?