Q&A: Past President, Present Blame

Q I’m a past president and current shareholder of a co-op. The current board is saying—that two years ago when I was president—I am responsible for decisions that the majority board decided back then. My apartment is for sale and the board is demanding payment of some of the expenses the board incurred two years ago before they will approve an interested buyer. All invoices and contracts I signed were done after either a majority board or shareholder vote. And all bills were paid via assessments or out of our holding account. What are my options?

—Confused in Jackson Heights

A “The board of directors may not condition its approval of an assignment of your proprietary lease and the transfer of the appurtenant shares on repayment of expenses incurred by a former board of directors of which you were a member,” says Peter Goodman, a partner at Hartman & Craven LLP, a Manhattan-based law firm. “From your question, it appears that the expenses were duly approved by the former board or shareholders. It seems the corporation has not obtained a judgment against you individually for the expenses based upon your alleged misconduct while you were a director. As a result, the corporation may not lawfully condition the transfer of your apartment on repayment of the expenses. If the corporation was permitted to impose this condition, it is difficult to see why anyone in your cooperative would want to serve on the board.

“Your proprietary lease and the bylaws of your apartment corporation likely grant the board of directors the right to impose conditions on the transfer of an apartment. However, the right to impose conditions is limited. Even without reviewing the lease and bylaws, it is reasonable to conclude that a court would find the requirement that a shareholder—who is a former officer and director—pay for a cooperative’s past expenses to constitute an unlawful condition, unless there had been some finding of misconduct.

“If you reach an impasse and the board refuses to relent, you have two options. First, you can sue the cooperative corporation and seek declaratory and injunctive relief, requiring the board of directors to approve the transfer without the condition of repayment of the expenses. Depending upon your proprietary lease, you may be entitled to recover your attorneys’ fees if you prevail. Second, you can pay the expenses under protest, proceed to closing, and then sue the cooperative to recover the expenses.”

Related Articles

2019 NY Rent Law Impacts Condo & Co-op Sector

Subletters Take Note!

Uncertainty, Confusion as Eviction Moratorium Ends

Differing Directives & Lack of Guidance Complicate an Already Tangled Picture

Update: Stay of Evictions Continues Although Moratorium Expires

Judge Issues New Guidance, Delays Hearings & Service of Warrants

Roommates and Boarders in Co-ops

What Are Your Rights?

Q&A: Of Mice and Management

Q&A: Of Mice and Management

Updating Your Documents

Is it Time for a Facelift?