Q&A: Paying for Home Improvement

Q “I live in a co-op in Queens. The front door to my apt. is being replaced—due to its extreme age it is no longer functioning properly. The manager informed me that I will be responsible for providing all of the hardware for this door—which includes a particular type of lock and handle, large metal mail slot, and even the hinges. This will cost over $120 because of the exact type of items needed to fit this particular door. Is this really my financial obligation? I thought the co-op was responsible for providing me with a working door.”

A —Aggrieved Apartment Owner

"Under applicable law,” says attorney Aaron Shmulewitz, a partner with the New York law firm of Belkin Burden Wenig & Goldman, LLP, “it is the obligation of the cooperative, as owner of the building, to provide a working, secure entrance door to the apartment, including at least one lock and a peephole. A shareholder, as tenant of the apartment, has the right to add an additional lock at his/her expense, but must provide a key to the cooperative. If the special lock, handle, mail slot and hinges on the prior door are not standard building equipment and were installed by the shareholder (or a predecessor), then the cooperative would be within its rights to require that the shareholder pay for their replacement. However, if those accessories are standard features in this building, then the co-op (and not the shareholder) must pay for them.”

Related Articles

Boards and the Law

How Statute and Governing Documents Intersect

Bankrolling the Board

The Question of Compensation

Foundational Documents for Co-ops & Condos

The Words That Get it Started