So, You've Been Sued Navigating a Lawsuit

Reading the papers you've just been served, your heart quickens in fight-or-flight mode. Part of your mind can't believe your eyes. You've just been sued, and you aren't sure what your next step should be.

To people who aren't lawyers or well-versed in the law, considering what to do once you've been sued can be a frightening thing. A small misstep might do more harm than good, or even get you shackled to testimony you didn't realize you were making. Who do you talk to, and what do you say? This legal quandary is even more difficult when the people involved in the dispute are members of the same community. What do you do if you are being sued as a member of the board for something that you know nothing about? Who do you call first?

In co-op and condo communities, a legal issue can pit neighbor against neighbor, and hard feelings will sometimes remain long after the argument has ended. Even in the most cordial of such communities, legal disputes can arise between a resident and the board, between two or more residents, or between a group of residents and the board or management company. Knowing where to step and how to respond after being slapped by a lawsuit can mean the difference between a quick end to the conflict or a protracted legal battle.

Making Your First Moves

After you've received word of the lawsuit, the first thing you should do is call your lawyer, advises David L. Berkey, managing partner of the Manhattan-based law firm of Gallet Dryer & Berkey LLC. "Second, notify your insurance company. It may be the liability carrier that is notified. If it's an individual, they should advise their carrier as well as the co-op's carrier on the suit," he says.

Acting properly after being served in a lawsuit is partly a matter of avoiding doing certain things. A person who has been served as party to a lawsuit would be foolish to ignore it, says attorney Steven Ganfer, a partner in Ganfer & Shore, based in Manhattan. "The lawsuit will not go away," he says. "After you've notified your counsel, follow up to make sure they're on top of [the suit]."


Related Articles

Keeping a Lid on Legal Costs

What Can Boards Do?

When the Noisy Neighbor … Is Literally Next Door

Dealing with Noise in a Neighboring Building

Mediation: A Potential Savior

How Co-ops and Condos Can Save Time, Money, and Face



  • What is the law when a person sues in one court he cannot sue for the same reason against the same party in another court?
  • Nice article. I appreciate the fact that despite the fact that you are a lawyer you are not trying to encourage increasing legal costs so that you guys can get paid more. I fell behind in my condo and HOA fees a couple of years back and they all have sued me. The original past due amounts are nothing in comparison to the condo and association legal costs which I am forced to pay. It has me feeling very bitter towards my fellow board neighbors who encourage these regulations. I would like to see more associations adopt a mediation program like you helped set up. Please come do it for my associations! It would have saved me thousands of dollars.