Q&A: My HDFC Co-op Won’t Transfer My Late Father’s Shares to Me

Q. I am an original and current shareholder in an HDFC co-op in Manhattan; I am on the lease and stock certificate along with my father (a co-shareholder). We both became shareholders along with the other existing tenants in the building at the time of conversion in 2000.

My father passed away in 2004. At the time, I gave proper notice to the building attorney via letters and a phone call. No follow-up was ever done by the board or building attorney. I have lived in the building and the apartment for over a decade paying my maintenance, attending elections, and voting. I am on the rent rolls. In addition, my father left a will, which has been fully probated in surrogate court. I am the sole beneficiary of his portion of the shares, as I already own mine. I am the executrix of the estate, as well as an existing shareholder.

The problem is the board refuses to transfer my father’s portion of his shares to me and provide an updated stock certificate with just my name – fourteen years after he passed away! They want my ‘current tax returns’ before transferring his shares. There is no policy or bylaw stating this as a requirement in our bylaws. We are not a Mitchell-Lama or limited equity building; we are private, and we don’t need to ‘income re-qualify’ every year or as an existing shareholder who is not purchasing any shares. How can I compel my board to transfer the shares, already? 

             —Inconvenienced by the Board 

A. “There is no one set of rules for HDFCs,” says partner Andrew Brucker at the Manhattan law office of Montgomery McCracken Walker & Rhoads LLP. “Some have a regulatory agreement with New York City, while others do not. And whereas all HDFCs have bylaws and lease, there is no requirement that they are all the same. 

Read More...

Related Articles

HDFC Co-op Real Estate Tax Foreclosures

A Slow-Moving Crisis in the Making

A Look at HDFCs

Understanding Housing Development Fund Corporation Co-ops

Q&A: Question About the Value of Shares After a Cooperator Dies

Q&A: Question About the Value of Shares After a Cooperator Dies

Upper Manhattan Forum Addresses HDFC Co-op Concerns

Assembly Member Holds Meeting to Discuss Ongoing Issues About HDFCs

Q&A: Producing a Stock Certificate for Inspection

Q&A: Producing a Stock Certificate for Inspection

Q&A: Does a Board Resolution at a Mitchell-Lama Building Become Part of the House Rules?

Q&A: Does a Board Resolution at a Mitchell-Lama Building Become Part of the House Rules?